Constitutional framework of indirect tax before GST

-

 Constitutional framework of indirect tax before GST

1. Service Tax

  • Definition: A tax imposed on services provided by businesses to customers. The service provider collects the tax from the customer and pays it to the government.
  • Applicability: Applied to a wide range of services including consulting, legal, and telecommunications services.
  • Rate History: Initially set at 14%, with additional cess increasing the effective rate to 15%. This tax was later replaced by the Goods and Services Tax (GST) starting July 1, 2017.
  • Exemption: Small service providers with annual revenue below INR 10 lakh were exempt from paying service tax.
  • Legislation: Governed by the Finance Act, 1994.

2. Excise Duty

  • Definition: A tax on the production or manufacture of goods within India. It is levied at the point of manufacture and is usually passed on to consumers as higher prices.
  • Applicability: Applies to a broad range of products, including alcohol, tobacco, and petroleum products.
  • Legislation: Governed by the Central Excise Act, 1944.
  • Rates: Vary based on the type of product. For instance, luxury goods often face higher excise duties compared to essential items.
  • Note: Excise duty was subsumed into GST for most goods, but it still applies to products like petroleum and tobacco.

3. Value Added Tax (VAT)

  • Definition: A tax on the value added to goods and services at each stage of production and distribution. VAT is paid by consumers but collected by businesses.
  • Applicability: Applied to the sale of movable goods. Each business collects VAT on sales and claims credit for VAT paid on purchases, ensuring that only the value added is taxed.
  • Authority: Levied by State Governments as per the Constitution of India under Entry 54 of the State List.
  • Rate Variation: VAT rates differ across states and types of goods. Essential items are often taxed at lower rates, while luxury items may attract higher rates.
  • Note: VAT was replaced by GST, which is a unified tax structure for both goods and services.

4. Customs Duty

  • Definition: A tax on goods imported into or exported from India. This tax is levied to regulate trade and protect domestic industries.
  • Applicability: Applied to goods entering or leaving the country. It helps control the balance of trade and can affect international trade agreements.
  • Legislation: Governed by the Customs Act, 1962.
  • Types:
    • Import Duty: Tax on goods brought into the country.
    • Export Duty: Tax on goods sent out of the country.
    • Anti-Dumping Duty: Additional tax on imported goods sold below their market value to protect domestic industries.
    • Countervailing Duty: Tax on imported goods to counteract subsidies provided by foreign governments.
  • Rates: Vary depending on the type of goods and their country of origin or destination.

5. Securities Transaction Tax (STT)

  • Definition: A tax on transactions involving securities traded on Indian stock exchanges.
  • Introduction: Introduced in 2004 to simplify taxation on securities transactions and replace short-term capital gains tax for such transactions.
  • Applicability: Applied to transactions involving stocks, mutual funds, futures, and options traded on recognized exchanges.
  • Rate: Varies depending on the type of transaction. For instance, the rate for equity shares is typically lower than for derivatives.
  • Legislation: Governed by the Finance Act, 2004.

6. Stamp Duty

  • Definition: A tax on legal documents and transactions related to the transfer of immovable property. It is collected by state governments.
  • Applicability: Applied to various legal documents, including property sales agreements, leases, and mortgages.
  • Rates: Vary by state and type of document. Rates can be influenced by the property value and the type of transaction.
  • Purpose: Ensures that the transfer of property and legal agreements are recorded and formalized.
  • Legislation: Governed by the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, and respective state laws.

7. Entertainment Tax

  • Definition: A tax imposed on activities related to entertainment, such as cinema tickets, amusement parks, and sports events.
  • Applicability: Collected by state governments on various entertainment activities and events.
  • Rates: Vary depending on the type of entertainment and the state.
  • Purpose: Aims to regulate and generate revenue from the entertainment sector.
  • Note: This tax was subsumed into GST for most entertainment services starting July 1, 2017.

Benefits of Indirect Taxes:

  • Contribution by the Poor: Allows everyone, including the poor, to contribute to tax revenue through consumption of goods and services.
  • Convenient: Taxes are collected at the point of sale, minimizing the administrative burden on taxpayers.
  • Easy Collection: Simplifies tax collection as it is incorporated into the price of goods and services, reducing evasion.
  • Equitable: Taxes correlate with consumption, meaning that wealthier individuals who purchase more expensive goods pay higher taxes.

Disadvantages of Indirect Taxes:

  • Regressive: Impact the poor disproportionately because the tax is applied uniformly to all consumers, regardless of their income.
  • Uncertain Revenue: Revenue from taxes on goods with elastic demand can be unpredictable as it depends on consumer behavior.
  • Industry Unfriendly: Can increase production costs if raw materials are taxed, affecting competitiveness and potentially leading to higher prices for consumers.

GST Implementation:

  • Overview: The Goods and Services Tax (GST) was introduced on July 1, 2017, to replace various indirect taxes including VAT, service tax, and excise duty. GST aims to simplify the tax structure, create a unified market, and reduce compliance costs by integrating multiple taxes into one.

This comprehensive view should help clarify the different types of indirect taxes and their implications.